MENU
CLOSE
The Law Platform
© Copyright 2021 - 2026
The High Court, Accra, sitting on the State Debt Recovery Cases in the General Jurisdiction Division in the case of RAMASAMY RUTHURUSAMY v. ATTORNEY-GENERAL & ORS [TLP-HC-2026-05], has ordered the Attorney-General, the Ghana Revenue Authority and the Economic and Organised Crime Office to pay a whistleblower a further GH¢3,749,113.73 with interest, holding that his tax-evasion disclosures against the Melcom Group of Companies were causally linked to later recoveries the state had tried to treat as unconnected to him.
The judgment, delivered on 30th January 2026 by Justice George Aikins Ampiah-Bonney (Jnr.), also found that the state agencies involved had consistently bypassed the Whistleblower Reward Fund established under the Whistleblower's Act, 2006 (Act 720), paying monetary rewards directly out of recovered funds instead, a practice the Court held was unlawful even if it had, until then, gone unchallenged.
Background
The plaintiff, Ramasamy Ruthurusamy, a former franchisee of Melcom, entered into a whistleblower agreement with the Economic and Organised Crime Office (EOCO) in April 2014, disclosing tax evasion committed by the Melcom Group between 2009 and 2014. Investigations conducted on the strength of his disclosures established a tax liability of GH¢31,865,811.46 against Melcom, which Melcom paid, along with a 25% penalty of GH¢7,966,452.87 imposed by the Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA).
EOCO subsequently asked the Attorney-General to have the 25% penalty released to it, both to cover its own operational costs and to pay the plaintiff his statutory 10% whistleblower reward. This request was approved by the then Finance Minister on the Attorney-General's advice, and GRA paid the full GH¢7,966,452.87 to EOCO. EOCO, in turn, paid the plaintiff GH¢3,186,581.00, roughly 10% of the original tax liability recovered, and retained the balance to defray its investigative expenses.
In November 2017, on legal advice, the plaintiff entered into a second whistleblower agreement, this time with the Ministry of Finance, disclosing further improprieties by Melcom, including tax evasion on imports, under-declaration, and money laundering, which he said the earlier assessment had not captured. These fresh disclosures were investigated by GRA with the assistance of the National Intelligence Bureau, leading to the arrest of Melcom's directors and a further recovery of GH¢34,592,561.43 from Melcom, bringing GRA's total recovery for the 2009-2019 period to GH¢69,356,943.87.
When the plaintiff demanded 10% of these additional recoveries, GRA refused, maintaining that it had already fully discharged its obligations by paying the GH¢7,966,452.87 to EOCO and that it owed the plaintiff nothing further. Dissatisfied, the plaintiff commenced the present action in January 2021 against the Attorney-General, GRA and EOCO, seeking a declaration that he was entitled to 10% of every recovery made from Melcom as a result of his disclosures, a consequential order for payment of GH¢3,459,256.14 said to be outstanding, interest, special damages of GH¢340,000.00 for printing costs, and costs.
The Plaintiff's Case
The plaintiff contended that, pursuant to Act 720, he was entitled to 10% of any recovery made to the state as a result of disclosures he had made. He argued that his second round of disclosures in 2017 led directly to the further recovery of GH¢34,592,561.43 from Melcom, and that GRA and EOCO, both described as creatures of statute and part of the executive arm of government, were jointly and severally liable to pay him his share of that recovery, which they had failed to do despite repeated demands.
The Defendants' Case
The Attorney-General denied being aware of the dealings between GRA and EOCO and denied that any whistleblower agreement had been entered into with the plaintiff in November 2017. GRA likewise denied being privy to any such 2017 agreement with the Ministry of Finance, denied having any whistleblower agreement of its own with the plaintiff, and argued that it was under no obligation to pay him compensation since such payments were the responsibility of a body established under Act 720. GRA maintained it had recovered a total of GH¢69,356,943.87 from Melcom for the 2009-2019 period through various audits and had already paid GH¢7,966,452.87 of that sum to EOCO.
EOCO, for its part, admitted entering into the original 2014 whistleblower agreement and admitted paying the plaintiff GH¢3,186,581.14, representing 10% of the GH¢31,865,811.46 tax liability it had helped establish. It explained that it paid this sum directly to the plaintiff, rather than through the Whistleblower Reward Fund, because the Fund contemplated under Act 720 had not yet been set up by government at the time. EOCO argued that once it completed its investigations and paid the plaintiff his reward, it played no further role in any subsequent recoveries from Melcom and owed him nothing more.
Court's Findings
The Court held that, in matters involving whistleblowers, the burden rests on the whistleblower only to show that his disclosure was a contributing factor to the action taken against the wrongdoer; once that is shown, the burden shifts to the defendant to prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that it would have taken the same recovery action regardless of the whistleblowing. Applying this standard, the Court found that GRA had failed to discharge the burden of showing that its identification and recovery of further tax liabilities from Melcom between 2016 and 2019 had no causal link to the plaintiff's disclosures. The Court noted that GRA had conducted no audit of Melcom's tax affairs of its own before the plaintiff's disclosures prompted EOCO's original investigation, undermining any suggestion that the subsequent recoveries arose independently of him.
While acknowledging that a whistleblower cannot claim a perpetual monopoly over every future recovery traceable, however distantly, to an initial disclosure, the Court held that recoveries made within a reasonable period are deemed to carry a direct causal link to the whistleblower's information, and found the period between 2009 and 2017 to fall within that reasonable window. On this basis, the Court held the plaintiff entitled to his claimed reliefs for a further consequential order, awarding him GH¢3,749,113.73, being the outstanding balance on the GH¢37,491,137.31 it found had been recovered from Melcom on the strength of his disclosures, together with interest on that sum at the prevailing commercial rate from 29th December 2017 until final payment.
The Court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for GH¢340,000.00 in special damages for printing costs, finding that he had failed to justify the amount as reasonable, remarking that the sum claimed could as easily have purchased capital printing equipment outright, and holding in any event that such incidental expenses were already subsumed within the 10% reward he had received and was being awarded.
On a point it considered important enough to address squarely, the Court found that none of the defendants had followed the procedure Act 720 prescribes for paying whistleblower rewards. Sections 20 to 24 of the Act establish a dedicated Whistleblower Reward Fund, funded by voluntary contributions and parliamentary allocations, from which alone monetary rewards to whistleblowers are to be paid. Instead, GRA had paid the 25% penalty directly to EOCO, and EOCO had in turn paid the plaintiff directly, bypassing the Fund entirely. The Court held that where a statute prescribes a specific procedure for securing a right, it is that procedure, and no other, which must be followed, rejecting the Attorney-General's submission that the Fund had simply never become operational and that paying whistleblowers out of recovered sums directly had become an accepted practice in its place.
Decision
The Court granted the plaintiff's reliefs for a further consequential order, directing the defendants to pay him GH¢3,749,113.73 with interest from 29th December 2017 until final payment, while dismissing his claim for GH¢340,000.00 in special damages for printing costs. The Court further directed that the balance of GH¢4,779,871.73 remaining from the GH¢7,966,452.87 earlier paid to EOCO, after deducting what had already gone to the plaintiff, be paid by EOCO into the Whistleblower Reward Fund rather than drawn from GRA, noting that EOCO had its own budgeted funds for its operations. It similarly directed that 10% of the further GH¢34,592,561.43 recovered from Melcom be paid from the Whistleblower Reward Fund going forward, and from no other source.
Unlock premium articles, PDF downloads, cases and more
Learn how to subscribe