MENU
CLOSE
The Law Platform
© Copyright 2021 - 2026
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council has overturned laws criminalising consensual same-sex sexual activity in Trinidad and Tobago, bringing an end to an 11-year legal battle led by LGBTQ+ rights activist Jason Jones. The landmark decision represents a significant development in the protection of constitutional rights, privacy and equality in the Caribbean.
The ruling, delivered on 10 November 2026, reverses an earlier decision by Trinidad and Tobago's Court of Appeal and restores the legal position established by the country's High Court in 2018, which had declared key provisions of the Sexual Offences Act unconstitutional.
Background to the Legal Challenge
The legal battle began in 2015 when Jason Jones, a dual citizen of Trinidad and Tobago and the United Kingdom, initiated proceedings challenging provisions of the country's Sexual Offences Act that criminalised consensual sexual activity between adults of the same sex.
The legislation prescribed criminal penalties for certain same-sex sexual acts, with provisions carrying the possibility of imprisonment. Jones argued that these restrictions violated fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution of Trinidad and Tobago, particularly the rights to privacy, equality and freedom from discrimination.
In 2018, the High Court ruled in his favour, finding that the relevant provisions were unconstitutional to the extent that they criminalised consensual sexual conduct between adults. The judgment was widely regarded as an important victory for LGBTQ+ rights in the Caribbean. However, the decision did not bring the legal dispute to an immediate conclusion.
Court of Appeal Reverses the Earlier Decision
The 2018 judgment was subsequently challenged, and in 2020, Trinidad and Tobago's Court of Appeal overturned the High Court's decision.
The reversal revived the legal uncertainty surrounding the criminalisation of same-sex sexual activity and prompted a further appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, which serves as the highest court of appeal for Trinidad and Tobago. The main issue before the Privy Council was whether the challenged statutory provisions could constitutionally criminalise consensual same-sex intimacy between adults.
5th Nov, 2026
25th Aug, 2026
19th Aug, 2026
29th Jul, 2026
14th Oct, 2025
Privy Council Rules in Favour of Jones
In its judgment delivered on 10 November 2026, the five-member Judicial Committee unanimously allowed Jones's appeal and dismissed the Attorney General's cross-appeal. The court held that sections 13 and 16 of the Sexual Offences Act 1986 were not protected from constitutional scrutiny by the savings provisions of the Constitution. It reasoned that the 1986 legislation constituted a new legal framework rather than merely reproducing pre-independence colonial laws.
The judges further found that criminalising private, consensual same-sex relations between adults constituted an unjustifiable interference with the fundamental rights of individuals. Delivering the judgment, Lord Sales emphasised that sexual orientation forms a core part of personal identity and falls within the protection afforded by the right to respect for private and family life. The court concluded that the provisions could not be regarded as reasonably justifiable in a society that respects individual rights and freedoms.
Colonial-Era Legislation and Constitutional Protection
One of the most significant aspects of the judgment concerns the relationship between colonial-era legislation and constitutional protections in former British colonies. The Attorney General had argued that the challenged provisions were protected by the Constitution's savings clauses, which preserve certain laws that existed before the adoption of the Constitution in 1976 from being invalidated on fundamental rights grounds.
However, the Privy Council rejected this argument. It found that the Sexual Offences Act 1986 introduced a new and comprehensive legislative framework and could not simply be treated as a continuation of earlier colonial legislation. The decision is particularly important for Commonwealth jurisdictions where similar savings clauses have historically been relied upon to defend laws inherited from British colonial administration.
By interpreting these constitutional protections narrowly, the Privy Council reaffirmed that legislative continuity does not automatically place existing laws beyond constitutional scrutiny, particularly where fundamental rights are concerned.
Significance for LGBTQ+ Rights in the Caribbean
The ruling has implications beyond Trinidad and Tobago. Several Caribbean countries continue to maintain laws criminalising consensual same-sex relations, many of which originated during British colonial rule. Human rights advocates have welcomed the decision as a potential catalyst for further constitutional challenges against similar legislation across the Commonwealth Caribbean.
The case also demonstrates the importance of strategic public interest litigation in advancing constitutional rights. Jones's 11-year legal challenge illustrates how individuals can use constitutional mechanisms and judicial processes to question laws that restrict fundamental freedoms.
Source: BBC
Unlock premium articles, PDF downloads, cases and more
Learn how to subscribe