MENU
CLOSE
The Law Platform
© Copyright 2021 - 2026
Events in the Criminal Court 4 division of the High Court, Accra presided over by H/L Justice Audrey Kocuvie-Tay, J. took a dramatic turn when the respected Victoria Barth, Lead Counsel for Solomon Asamoah in the case of Republic v Solomon Asamoah & Prof. Ameyaw-Akumfi (Case No. CR/0448/2025) withdrew her legal representation for Solomon Asamoah over the refusal of the Court to stay proceedings pending a certiorari application before the Supreme Court and a motion to suspend an order of Justice Kocuvie-Tay for Mr. Solomon Asamoah to testify first before his subpoenaed witnesses contrary to the preferred order of call of witnesses of Mr. Asamoah.
According to Mrs. Barth, per Court notes of today, 16th November, 2026, a copy of which is below; "Respectfully, the court leaves me no choice but to withdraw my representation of A1 at this stage as I am unable to comply with a directive which in my respectful view is inconsistent with A1's constitutional right to remain silent and not to be compelled to give evidence in a manner that prejudices his defence."
In justifying her withdrawal, Mrs. Barth submitted that, "Furthermore, I cannot be a willing party to proceedings that undermine the very applications I have filed before the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. I regret very much that it has come to this and I pray the court in the circumstances to afford A1 the opportunity t o instruct new counsel who may lead him to testify."
The Order under attack
On the 29th day of October, 2026, the Court ordered that it "will receive evidence from A1 and A 2 and thereafter give dates and directions as to when the subpoenaed witnesses would be taken. Counsel for A1 is notified that at any time when a date is given t o a witness and that witness is unavailable the next witness could be called in order not to waste the time of the court."
Mrs. Victoria Barth objected to the order of calling the witness of Mr. Asamoah and informed the Court of the desire of defence to have subpoenaed witnesses testify before Mr. Solomon Asamoah testifies. Mr. Asamoah, 1st accused, is subpoenaing 15 witnesses.
13th Nov, 2026
9th Nov, 2026
2nd Nov, 2026
30th Oct, 2026
27th Oct, 2026
Mrs. Barth argued that the Court ought to allow defence call witnesses in the order indicated as the order of calling is consistent with the structure of the defence Mr. Asamoah has marshalled against the charges of the A-G. In her words per the Court notes dated 29th October, 2026, a copy which is below; "...A1 in the order that I intend to conduct his defence is the last person I would be calling and it is my respectful submission that the court must allow us the opportunity to structure the defense in the order that best serves A1's interest."
The Republic strongly resisted the suggestion on grounds of same being "against logic, against law and in fact against any principle o f efficiency to seek t o call a witness who is not available yet before calling a witness who is available and file his witness statement. We therefore pray that my lady dismisses this prayer by counsel."
Supreme Court and Court of Appeal Invoked Against Order of Call of Defence Witnesses
Lawyers for A1, Solomon Asamoah, have lodged an appeal against the decision of Justice Kocuvie-Tay at the Court of Apeal citing personal interest and a descent into the arena of conflict as part of the particulars of the grounds of law of the Appeal.
A copy of the notice of appeal may be read/downloaded below.
COURT NOTES TODAY, MONDAY, 16/11/2026 ON WITHDRAWAL OF MRS. BARTHS'S LEGAL REPRESENTATION
COURT NOTES FOR 29TH OCTOBER, 2026 ON ORDER FOR CALLING OF DEFENCE WITNESSES
NOTICE OF APPEAL AGAINST ORDER ON 29TH OCTOBER, 2026
MOTION FOR STAY OF PROCEEDINGS
Unlock premium articles, PDF downloads, cases and more
Learn how to subscribe