MENU
CLOSE
The Law Platform
© Copyright 2021 - 2026
The High Court in Accra has ordered the majority shareholders of Geromino Data Systems Africa Ltd to personally buy out the shares of two former senior executives, after finding that the company's affairs were run in disregard of their interests as minority shareholders. In the same judgment, the Court declared that the former chief executive breached his fiduciary duty by holding unauthorised conflicting interests in three other companies, but refused the company any compensation or account of profits because it proved no loss and no profit.
The judgment delivered on 24 July 2026 by the learned Justice Afia N. Adu-Amankwa at Commercial Court 9 in the case of GEROMINO DATA SYSTEMS AFRICA LTD v. HUSSAM OCKAILI & ORS [TLP-HC-2026-98] offers an exciting judicial cocktail of a judicial discussion and application of important, business-sense company law principles including conflict of interest, corporate governance, shareholding by directors of the company, oppression among others.
The decision demonstrates consequences of business creation and operations on family and trust relationships rather than sound corporate practices and intentional compliance with laws and constitutions regulating Companies.
Background
Geromino Data Systems Africa Ltd, incorporated on 3 January 2005, sells information technology equipment and solutions. Hussam Ockaili served as its chief executive officer from 2007 and held 10% of the shares, while Horace Wangnin Saizonou was general manager and held 3%. Both resigned in mid-September 2016, Mr. Saizonou on 13 September and Mr. Ockaili on 14 September. The company's majority shareholders are Charles Laba and Wissam Laba.
The company sued the two former executives, alleging that between June 2015 and September 2016 they conspired to run it down in favour of a rival, H2 Solutions Limited. It claimed they let its Oracle partnership licence lapse, costing it an MTN contract, enticed staff to leave, falsely told clients it was closing, moved its corporate mobile lines to another company they owned, and diverted funds through third-party companies. It also sought the return of four company vehicles in their possession. The defendants denied all of this and counterclaimed against the company and the two Labas, alleging oppression of minority shareholders, unauthorised withdrawals of company funds, a unilaterally imposed management fee, no dividends declared through proper process, and constructive dismissal. They claimed end-of-service benefits of USD$144,000 and USD$108,000, and a buy-out of their shares at USD$1,000,000 and USD$300,000.
9th Nov, 2026
6th Nov, 2026
29th Oct, 2026
26th Aug, 2026
28th Jul, 2026
The Court adopted thirty-one issues for trial but grouped them into broader subject areas. It also observed that the title of the suit misdescribed the parties to the counterclaim, since the company itself was a defendant to it. It treated this as a defect of form that caused no prejudice and proceeded on corrected designations.
The Plaintiff's Case
Through Wissam Laba, the company argued that the defendants were brought in as staff from a Laba family company and given their shares at nominal value as a gesture to secure their loyalty. It said they resigned voluntarily to set up competing businesses, and had planned this for over a year, pointing to the incorporation of Technology H2 Solutions in the United Kingdom in June 2015. It relied on an MTN email of 7 March 2017 as proof that the loss of the Oracle licence cost it the MTN contract. It also argued that dividends were paid to the defendants in 2016 and that the majority shareholders had put more money into the company than they had taken out.
The Defendants' Case
The defendants said they turned the company from near insolvency into one worth over USD$10 million, and that their shares were earned for that work. They said the majority shareholders took large sums for personal use without board approval, ran the company without ever holding board meetings, and threatened to remove them whenever they objected. They pointed to the Laba family's own parallel companies, Red Mango, Fruit Basket and CIS Ghana, and said the Oracle licence lapsed only after handover, on the watch of the new management. They said they kept the vehicles as security for what they were owed.
The Court's Findings
The shareholding: The Court held that the shares were not issued under any employee incentive scheme. The only documents were the share transfer forms, which showed absolute transfers for GHC50.00 and GHC13.50. The plaintiff's witness conceded that there was no documented scheme, and the timing of the transfers in 2010, about three years after the defendants joined, fitted the defendants' account that the shares rewarded past work. The defendants were therefore genuine minority shareholders protected by the Companies Code, 1963 (Act 179).
The Oracle licence and the MTN contract: The Court found that the licence lapsed through a shared failure in a disordered handover, not deliberate sabotage. The defendants had resigned before Oracle's final reminder of 18 October 2016, and the incoming management had the vendor details and access to the defendants' monitored email accounts. The defendants' omission was failing to convey the urgency of the renewal. On the MTN contract, the Court held that MTN's rejection cited two deficiencies, the missing Oracle licence and the absence of certified resources, and the plaintiff led no evidence explaining the second or MTN's scoring. It therefore failed to prove that the licence was the operative cause of the loss.
H2 Solutions, staff and the telephone lines: Technology H2 Solutions was incorporated in England on 22 June 2015 and dissolved on 6 December 2016 without trading. H2 Solutions Limited in Ghana was a dormant shell company, originally Punchline Travel & Tours Limited, re-registered under its new name on 9 September 2016, days before the resignations, which undermined the defendants' account that it was a 1998 family company. Neither entity did any business before the resignations. About eight former employees later joined H2 Solutions, but the Court found no proof that the defendants orchestrated this while still in office, apart from admitted approaches to one former staff member, Evelyn Atuobi, who had already left. The corporate mobile lines were moved to ITTS on 22 March 2016, not July as pleaded, in an open transfer copied to the defendants in their official roles, and no business was shown to have been diverted.
ITTS and Multi "B" Ventures: The Court found that ITTS Ghana Limited, incorporated on 2 April 2014 and owned by the two defendants, was known to and tolerated by the Labas as part of the group. It attached considerable weight to Wissam Laba's concessions under cross-examination, including that parts of his witness statement alleging siphoning of funds were wrong and that ITTS was held in trust for the majority shareholders. Multi "B" Ventures, incorporated on 14 June 2013, did business with MTN between November 2013 and January 2014, but the plaintiff identified no specific opportunity diverted to it.
Fiduciary duty: On section 203(2) of Act 179, the Court held that none of these allegations showed the first defendant acting otherwise than in the company's best interests, and it noted that planning to compete after leaving is not in itself a breach. Under sections 205 and 206, however, it found that the first defendant placed himself in positions of conflict in relation to H2 Solutions, Multi "B" Ventures and ITTS, none of which was authorised by the company in the manner section 206 requires. Knowledge or acquiescence by the majority shareholders was not enough. The remedies in section 209, however, depend on proof of loss or of profit made through the breach, and the plaintiff proved neither, so the claims failed at the remedy stage. The Court did not extend its fiduciary findings to the second defendant, who was never a director of the company.
Oppression: Under section 218 of Act 179, the Court held that the defendants did not prove oppression in the strict sense, because there was no deliberate campaign to harm them or force them out, and many of the governance failings affected the company generally. It was nevertheless satisfied that the company's affairs were conducted in disregard of their proper interests as minority shareholders. No board meeting was ever held, large transfers were made on emailed instructions from the Labas for their personal benefit without board authority, a monthly group management fee of USD$50,000 was imposed without approval, no true dividend was declared before 2016, and the minority had no real voice in decisions about their investment. The Court noted that the Labas ran several parallel companies without disclosure while criticising the defendants for doing the same. It accepted that the defendants processed many of the transfers, but held that they did so on the majority's instructions, within a structure that gave them no means of objecting. It did not adopt the defendants' figure of GHC4,910,390.52 for unaccounted withdrawals, since the audited statements they approved showed a directors' account balance of about GHC255,305.
The remaining claims: The Court dismissed the defendants' request for a declaration that the Labas breached fiduciary duties to the defendants, holding that such duties are owed to the company and that the defendants had brought no derivative action under section 210. The constructive dismissal claim under section 63(3) of the Labour Act, 2003 (Act 651) failed because the defendants' preparations for independent ventures, including the two H2 Solutions entities and ITTS, meant they had not shown that the employer's conduct was the operative cause of their resignations. The end-of-service claims failed because no salary records proved the base figures and the informal practice was not shown to bind the company. The defendants' claimed lien over the vehicles also failed, as none of the recognised categories of lien applied and holding the vehicles was an act of self-help. There was no proved non-compete covenant, so the plaintiff's request for a restraining order failed.
The Decision
The Court ordered Charles Laba and Wissam Laba to buy the defendants' shares in their personal capacities, rather than making the company buy them, so that the company's capital is not used to fund a remedy made necessary by the majority's own conduct. The price will be fixed by an independent valuer, to be agreed within twenty-one days or appointed by the Court, who must value the company as at 14 September 2016 on a going-concern basis and report within ninety days. The Court rejected the defendants' self-assessed prices of USD$1,000,000 and USD$300,000 for want of valuation evidence, and held that nothing could be set off against the price because the plaintiff's claims for loss and profits had failed. The valuer's cost is shared equally. Until the purchase is completed, the defendants remain registered shareholders with full membership rights. The Court declined a separate order for accounts, since the valuer will examine the company's finances, and declined to remove Mr. Ockaili as a director, leaving the company to use the procedure in section 185 of Act 179.
The Court also declared that Mr. Ockaili breached his fiduciary duty by holding unauthorised conflicting interests in H2 Solutions, Multi "B" Ventures and ITTS, and ordered the defendants to return the four vehicles (the KIA Cerato, KIA Sorento, Land Rover Freelander and Ford Explorer) within twenty-one days, with liberty for the plaintiff to apply if any cannot be returned or is not in proper condition. Costs were reserved until the valuation is complete.
Counsel: Kwadwo Akowuah Denteh Owusu-Ansah, led by Gregory Kwadwo Asiedu, for the plaintiff; Ekow Dadson for the defendants.
Unlock premium articles, PDF downloads, cases and more
Learn how to subscribe