MENU
CLOSE
The Law Platform
© Copyright 2021 - 2026
Two lawyers working for the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) are facing potential disciplinary action following separate incidents involving the misuse of artificial intelligence (AI) in their legal work. The cases, investigated by the department's Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR), involved the submission of court documents containing fabricated legal quotations and the unauthorised disclosure of confidential government information through a publicly available AI platform.
The findings, released on 17 November 2026, revealed violations of professional conduct rules by both lawyers and have reignited concerns about the ethical and professional implications of integrating generative AI into legal practice. The findings were subsequently referred to the department's Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which has the authority to impose disciplinary measures.
Fabricated Legal Quotations and Misleading Statements to the Court
In the first incident, an Assistant United States Attorney submitted a court filing containing fabricated quotations and inaccurate representations of judicial decisions. The document misrepresented case holdings and included quotations that could not be traced to the authorities cited.
When the presiding judge questioned the inaccuracies, the prosecutor initially failed to disclose that artificial intelligence had been used in preparing the document. Instead, the lawyer attributed the errors to accidentally filing an earlier draft.
The DOJ's Office of Professional Responsibility subsequently established that the prosecutor had used generative AI and made false or misleading statements to the judge when questioned about the errors.
The misconduct therefore extended beyond the use of an AI tool that generated inaccurate legal material. It also involved a failure of candour towards the court, an obligation fundamental to the administration of justice and the professional responsibilities of legal practitioners.
16th Nov, 2026
11th Nov, 2026
9th Nov, 2026
2nd Nov, 2026
30th Oct, 2026
The second investigation concerned another DOJ attorney who uploaded work-related documents to a publicly accessible AI platform despite restrictions imposed by a court order and departmental policies.
The documents included material subject to a tribunal's protective order, which restricted how the information could be shared. The investigation also identified documents containing personally identifiable information belonging to department employees, including medical information.
The OPR concluded that the attorney had recklessly violated professional conduct rules by using the public AI platform in breach of departmental policy. It further found that the lawyer had knowingly and intentionally violated professional obligations by uploading confidential departmental documents. The attorney was also found to have knowingly breached the tribunal's protective order.
The incident highlights the confidentiality risks associated with entering sensitive professional information into publicly accessible AI systems without appropriate authorisation or safeguards.
Justice Department Refers Both Cases for Disciplinary Action
Following its investigations, the OPR referred both matters to the DOJ's Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which is responsible for considering disciplinary action against department lawyers.
The findings were published without identifying the lawyers involved, their respective offices or whether they remained employed by the department. The AI platforms used in both incidents were also not disclosed. It remains unclear whether the findings will be referred to state bar authorities responsible for regulating and enforcing professional standards among lawyers.
In a statement, the Justice Department maintained that it takes its responsibility to investigate and address allegations of professional misconduct seriously and would continue to follow established procedures.
Increasing Alarms Over AI Misuse in Legal Practice
The two incidents reflect a pattern of issues about the use of generative AI in legal proceedings. Across different jurisdictions, lawyers have faced judicial criticism and disciplinary consequences for relying on AI-generated information without verifying its accuracy.
In May 2026, a North Carolina state bar grievance committee publicly reprimanded a former federal prosecutor after a court brief submitted in a veterans' healthcare benefits dispute contained fabricated quotations and other inaccuracies attributed to AI use.
Similar concerns have emerged in other cases involving fictitious judicial authorities, invented witness testimony and inaccurate representations of court decisions. These incidents demonstrate that the risks of AI misuse extend beyond unreliable legal research to include breaches of confidentiality, failures of candour and violations of professional obligations.
Unlock premium articles, PDF downloads, cases and more
Learn how to subscribe