MENU
CLOSE
The Law Platform
© Copyright 2021 - 2026
A British holidaymaker is suing her former solicitors for £4.5 million in damages after an alleged professional negligence resulted in the loss of her personal injury claim against travel company TUI. The claim follows a 2017 incident in which a 50-foot coconut palm tree fell on her while she was sunbathing at a hotel resort in Sri Lanka.
Background to the Incident
The claimant, Claire Saywell, was on holiday with her husband at the four-star Club Hotel Dolphin resort in Waikkal, Sri Lanka, in 2017 when the coconut palm tree fell on her as she rested on a sun lounger.
The impact caused severe injuries to her legs, which were reportedly bent backwards at the knees. She underwent emergency surgery in Colombo before being flown back to the United Kingdom for further treatment.
According to the evidence presented in court, Saywell underwent approximately ten operations and continues to experience significant pain and physical disabilities. She was also reportedly forced to leave her employment as an insurance consultant and required alternative accommodation suited to her injuries.
Following the incident, she instructed Slater and Gordon UK Ltd to pursue a personal injury claim against TUI, the travel company through which she had booked the holiday.
Solicitors Admit Breach of Professional Duty
The original claim against TUI was subsequently struck out after the solicitors allegedly served the relevant legal documents at an incorrect email address belonging to TUI's solicitors.
Slater and Gordon has admitted breaching its professional duty by failing to validly serve the claim form within the required period. However, the firm disputes that Saywell is entitled to compensation, arguing that the original claim against TUI would probably not have succeeded. The dispute has therefore shifted from the circumstances of the accident to whether the claimant lost a genuine opportunity to obtain compensation because of her solicitors' negligence.
16th Nov, 2026
5th Nov, 2026
25th Aug, 2026
19th Aug, 2026
29th Jul, 2026
Dispute Over the Chances of Success
At a preliminary hearing, Saywell's barrister, Howard Elgot, argued that the original claim against TUI had strong prospects of success.
A key issue concerns the condition of the coconut palm before it fell. An arborist who had previously examined the evidence reportedly identified damage and possible rot at the base of the tree, allegedly caused by a spike and concrete driven into it to secure a utility line.
The expert's preliminary view was that coconut palms would not ordinarily fall during high winds unless they were already weakened or rotten. This evidence could support an argument that the accident was not simply an unavoidable natural occurrence but may have resulted from inadequate maintenance.
However, Slater and Gordon's barrister, Clare Elliot, disputed the strength of the original claim, arguing that its prospects of success did not exceed 51%. The firm also contested the £4.5 million damages figure. The court granted Saywell permission to rely on further expert arboricultural evidence to establish the condition of the tree and assess the prospects of the original claim.
Legal Significance: The Loss of a Chance
The proceedings illustrate the legal principle of loss of a chance in professional negligence claims.
Where a solicitor's negligence causes a client to lose the opportunity to pursue an underlying legal claim, the solicitor may be liable for the value of the opportunity lost. However, the claimant must establish that the original claim had a real and substantial prospect of success.
Consequently, admitting professional negligence does not automatically establish liability for the full amount claimed. The court must still consider whether the original proceedings would probably have resulted in a successful settlement or judgment and assess the value of that lost opportunity.
Conclusion
The case highlights the importance of procedural compliance and professional diligence in legal practice. A failure to meet a deadline or correctly serve court documents can have consequences extending far beyond administrative inconvenience, potentially depriving clients of their opportunity to obtain legal redress.
Although Slater and Gordon has admitted the breach of duty, the extent of its financial liability remains contested. The proceedings also demonstrate that professional negligence claims require courts to examine not only whether a solicitor made a mistake but also the consequences of that mistake for the client's underlying case. The parties are reportedly considering alternative dispute resolution as a possible means of settling the dispute.
Source: The Law Society Gazette
Unlock premium articles, PDF downloads, cases and more
Learn how to subscribe